Show and Tell

Here’s an interesting post that talks about why the concept of “Show, not tell” sometimes works better with a film’s audience.

“If you show the actions of a character, the audience will make their own judgements of who that character is and what they want. These judgements of the characters combine in the audience’s minds to build up their own stories about the ingredients of your movie. One of the tricks then is to let the audience sometimes get ahead of the characters and at other times let them fall behind.”

These are concepts that can be written into a story obviously, but they also can be affected in the edit suite.

However, consider that this concept doesn’t always work in every situation: In “The Dark Knight”, for instance, there was no “show” backstory on the Joker. Typically superhero movies use flashbacks or some way of quickly bringing the audience up to speed on the motivations of the character. In “Dark Knight,” the Nolan brothers had the Joker “tell” his own backstory, the only caveat being that the stories varied wildly upon each subsequent telling, and the overall effect was in fact to “show” his insanity. It’s a refreshing approach that seems to be a hybrid of both “show” and “tell.” Think about these principles as you write and edit your next project.


2 Responses to “Show and Tell”  

  1. 1 Kendal Miller

    Interesting take Matt. I think it is one instance where telling worked really well because as he retold it like you said you gained insight into the characters psyche I think you would miss just watching it. The way he recounted it added a sense of separation from the past a degree of emotional coldness removed from the brutality of anything that would have happened in his past. Had you actually SEEN these events I think you as the audience would have sided too heavily with his character out of sympathy rather than buying into the whole mentality that, “Some men just want to watch the world burn.”

  2. 2 Matthew Jeppsen

    I totally agree, Kendal. It was probably the best way to script that.

    -MJ

Rodney's Adsense-Deluxe Add ons plugged in.